If Students Had This One Trait, They Could Be Successful
Keith W. Sun // University of Cincinnati
Abstract: Not all students shine equally when climbing the professional ladder of success. There is a particular trait that is underneath a lot of the soft skills and professionalism students learn inside and outside the classroom. Humility leads to success. Through helpful examples, professional illustrations, and practical tips for educators, this article will explore humility in its multiple dimensions to help readers discern when humility is present and celebrate its fruits as students demonstrate them.
I come across a lot of students. It helps working in the Lindner Career Services Center at the University of Cincinnati. We teach, coach, and counsel students towards career success for internships and co-ops, especially full-time employment upon graduation. Including both individual and drop-in coaching appointments, I see more than 500 students annually. I teach more than 180 students every school year in undergraduate Career Success Strategies courses. Suffice it to say, there are a lot of students that I interact with, who come and go through the office door and the classroom.
Some students are more successful than others in the present, or will be in the near future. I define success as someone who has developed strong skills and relational connections that can be leveraged towards professional or personal accomplishment with enduring life satisfaction.
What distinguishes these students from the rest? What is one trait that endears them to my memory and gives me confidence in their personal and professional lives?
Is it technical skills? No.
Is it a great smile on their face? Nope.
Is it straight A’s? Not even.
The one trait that makes students successful is humility.
Why do I say that? Here’s how humility looks to me and why it gives me such confidence in students’ future success from a career services standpoint:
Adam is a fourth-year business student at the University of Cincinnati. He studies Operations Management and transferred into the business college as a sophomore from a different university. Because he had to pay his way through college, Adam worked two jobs while enrolled as a full-time student. He served as a cashier at a major international supermarket, and simultaneously worked a second shift in a warehouse distribution center as a fulfillment associate. I’ve had the opportunity to teach Adam in a class as well as meet with him individually on his career goals. I’ve never found Adam on his cell phone or tablet, distracted from the people around him, even while waiting to see me. He always spoke about the valuable skills he learned in his jobs, despite not having experienced an internship like many of his peers. Adam never complained and effusively expressed his gratitude to me and any other college employee he came across. When in my morning class, other students would doze off and overlook the importance of the lecture content. Adam never wavered in being prepared and having the willingness to ask questions, without giving others any hint that he was sleep-deprived and stressed from the long hours at work.
His humility was evident, and Adam recently secured two offers for internships working in facilities management and automotive manufacturing.
This is what humility can lead to:
Mallory is a third-year business student at the University of Cincinnati. She studies Marketing and Entrepreneurship as her declared majors, after having transferred into the business college as a sophomore from a liberal arts program on campus. Mallory is also a student-athlete who won a full-tuition scholarship to run track and cross-country here at UC. Having gotten to know Mallory through teaching her in class, Mallory approached me to introduce herself and to express concern about a potential conflict between her track meets and our class meeting times. Over the course of the semester, she consistently stood out as one who raised her hand in every awkward silence. Though Mallory was an accomplished athlete, she never flaunted any kind of ego, entitlement, disrespect, or disengagement. She willingly came to her career coach for multiple individual appointments, always asking for extra ways to improve on her resume and job search. Mallory ultimately threw her resume in to apply for a Teaching Assistant position for the Career Success Strategies undergraduate course. After competing against other candidates who were all honors students, she became the only non-honors student to obtain a TA position. Mallory easily won the respect of my colleagues who interviewed her because she communicated how much she benefited from the course and how she wanted to give back to those who were less informed or less concerned about their career goals.
In her humility, Mallory maintained poise in the face of managing a grueling training schedule with full-time classes. Her teammates nominated her at the end of the season to be the next school year’s Team Captain. Mallory did not concern herself with how she was viewed when she asked questions or sat in a group of polished honors students. She chose not to stop calling me “Professor,” out of respect, even though I made it clear to students that I prefer to be addressed on a first-name basis.
How can we as educators celebrate and teach humility? There are multiple possibilities and the context of each university may inform different practices. However, here are a few suggestions:
First, refine the university’s admissions process for students in order to emphasize humility factors – overcoming difficult challenges, volunteering with the socially overlooked or
forgotten, enthusiastically giving credit to others more than themselves, or having a strong network of mentors.
Second, include more assignments that require students to reflect on and assess mistakes
they’ve made, failures they’ve experienced, and risks that didn’t turn out the way they hoped. Let
students dig deeply into what they’ve learned and what good outcomes came from experiencing
what they did.
Third, get rid of self-nominations for any awards given to students for exemplary service
or leadership. If someone is truly humble, they won’t be thinking of themselves, but thinking of others. Let the award reflect others’ praise and not their own.
Fourth, encourage mentorship wherever possible. The more students realize they don’t
know as much as they suppose, the less inflated an ego they will possess.
Lastly, celebrate professors and campus staff who are willing to help with tasks and projects that would be considered beneath their pay grade. For example, recognize a powerful educational administrator who willingly gives up a reserved parking spot for a day so that a student with a long commute can make it to class on time. If students see that strong acknowledgment is given to those who occasionally give up their privileges for the benefit of others, the culture changes and humility can be contagious.
A wise proverb once said:
“Pride leads to destruction, but humility leads to honor.” (Contemporary English Version, Proverbs 18:12)
My hope is that we honor the students who have humility, and that there may be more students who “get it” and build humility into their lives.
Contemporary English Version. Bible Gateway, www.biblegateway.com. Accessed March 30, 2019.